The 17 Best Crib Sheets: Non Toxic and Organic Crib Sheets Only

Share this Post

The best crib sheets for your baby, including my favorite non toxic and organic crib sheets, and what you want to look for when shopping. Includes fit tests on 4 popular crib mattresses plus my personal experiences with these crib sheets!

Best crib sheets and best organic crib sheets

How Important are Organic Crib Sheets?

First of all, let me say: I’m not an organic cotton die hard, and I don’t think you need to be either.

That’s why I’ve called this article “Non Toxic and Organic Crib Sheets,” rather than focusing entirely on organic crib sheets. If you’re looking for the best organic crib sheets, you’ll still find them in this article! But also, I’ve included some other options.

I own some organic crib sheets, and also some conventional ones. They all have pros and cons.

If you can afford organic cotton for your crib sheets, by all means, go for it. There are a lot of benefits to doing so, which I’ve laid out later in this article.

But if you can’t afford organic cotton, that’s okay too. In that case, I suggest you focus your attention on what kinds of inks and dyes the company uses, and make sure they are water-based, non-toxic, and/or azo free. Because that does matter, in my opinion, when it comes to safety.

While organic baby stuff does tend to be more expensive, you can find a fairly wide range at an affordable price these days.

There are certainly super bougie brands out there, but major retailers like Target, Walmart and Amazon have pretty affordable options. Burt’s Bees Baby crib sheets are a brand I have used personally and can recommend, and they can be found for a fairly affordable price, either through their two-packs on Amazon, or on the sale section on the Burt’s Bees Baby website (I’ve even seen organic crib sheets on there for about the same price as a Starbucks coffee, before!). KeaBabies on Amazon also tends to have affordable organic crib sheets that are GOTS certified.

That said, I don’t think organic crib sheets are essential, and would argue the dyes and pigments are a more important barometer of “non toxic.”

I’ve formed this opinion based on my own research, looking at peer reviewed studies, and laid out in my articles about whether organic cotton is safer for babies and kids, and why azo free inks are a good idea for babies and kids.

Key Takeaways About Whether You Need Organic Cotton Crib Sheets

  • Organic cotton is definitely a more environmentally friendly choice as compared to conventional cotton, and in an idea world we’d all be able to afford it. If you can afford it, it’s a great choice for this reason, as well as some other reasons I’ve laid out further in this article.
  • Some cotton products are absolutely worth buying organic. Anything with cotton batting in the finished product (i.e. quilts, duvets, mattresses, pillows), buy organic if you can. That’s because conventional cotton batting tends to retain some of the pesticide residue and chemicals used when growing and harvesting the crop. My family sleeps on organic mattresses (me and my husband, and my daughter) for this reason.
  • Buying organic when we’re talking about finished fabrics (i.e. clothes and sheets) is less important from a “pesticide residue” point of view. That’s because pesticide residues tend to be gone when it comes to finished fabrics. This isn’t my opinion – people have studied this, and I personally feel sources that claim pesticide residue is a problem in finished cotton fabrics are being misleading.
  • When considering finished fabric products, such as sheets, consider what kind of dyes the company used. While pesticide residues in finished conventional cotton fabric does not appear to be a widespread problem we need to worry too much about, heavy metal contamination from dying cotton with toxic dyes DOES appear to be a problem worth our consideration as parents. Most organic cotton sheets also use non-toxic dyes, making it an easy “two birds, one stone” purchase, but it’s always worth double checking on the dyes.

Crib Sheets with Safe Dyes and Pigments > Organic Crib Sheets

I’ve chosen to focus this article on non-toxic and organic crib sheets, rather than organic baby crib sheets only.

I hope it offers you more choice, and also allows you to choose sheets in a budget range that suits your family.

I’ve started out by listing some non-toxic and organic sheets I think are great. I’ve used some of them personally, and am able to offer my personal experiences with those ones, including testing them out on a few different crib mattresses for fit.

Other brands I haven’t had the chance to use personally yet, but I’ve included them in this list based on research into the brand.

I believe the best crib sheets are ones that use safe fabrics AND safe dyes and pigments, as well as being user friendly for parents (washing, getting on the crib mattress) and soft and safe for baby. I hope this article helps you make a choice that’s right for your family.

My Personal Experience with these Non Toxic Organic Crib Sheets

Of the 17 brands of organic and non toxic crib sheets I recommend in this article, I have personally used and tested 4 of them: Burt’s Bees Baby, Little Unicorn, Pehr, and Pottery Barn Kids.

I have yet to try the Naturepedic crib sheets, although I love our Naturepedic mattresses, so feel confident recommending the brand.

The other options I’ve included on this list of best crib sheets are based on research, not personally trying and testing them. That includes: Nestig, Avocado, Natemia, Green Cradle, Our Green House,

I also haven’t used any of the sheets in the Alternatives Section, including Touched by Nature, Pickle & Pumpkin, KeaBabies, Lewis Home, West Elm Kids, Kindred + Kid Baby, and Honest Baby.

Also worth noting, of the crib sheets I own, I have tested them on 4 different crib mattresses for fit and ease of getting on and off: Naturepedic Breathable, Lullaby Earth, a Nook Sleep Pebble Mattress, and Colgate Eco Classica III. As far as the Nook Mattress, I tested it on the Nook Air, which seems to be out of stock everywhere. However, it’s the same dimensions as the Nook Pebble Pure which is still available!

Table of Contents

17 Best Crib Sheets (Non Toxic and Organic)

Best Overall: Burts Bees Crib Sheets

We give Burts Bees Organic Crib Sheets 5/5

A grey stiped jersey knit Burts Bees organic cotton crib sheet fitting on a crib mattress. Burts bees makes one of the best crib sheets on the market due to being soft, durable, non toxic and organic.

Our Burt’s Bees Baby Sheet in Grey Stripe

Best Organic Crib Sheets + Best Jersey Knit Crib Sheets

We own these crib sheets, and I can’t say enough good things about them. Soft, cozy, and durable, they come in a wide range of adorable designs, too.

Check Prices, Colors, and Designs
(Available at Amazon, Burts Bees, or Target, and other retailers)

  • Certifications: GOTS
  • Made in: India
  • Made from: 100% GOTS certified organic cotton jersey knit with GOTS regulated dyes and printing techniques
  • Care instructions: Machine wash cold on the gentle cycle with like colors and tumble dry low. If required, only use non-chlorine bleach
  • Size: 28″ x 52″. Fits a standard US crib mattress up to 6″ in depth
  • Elastic: The elastic runs around the entire perimeter of the sheet

We own these sheets, and can speak with personal experience about how great they are.

A woman's hand holds the tag in a Burt's Bees baby crib sheet. The label indicates it is made form 100% organic cotton and made in India.

The cotton jersey knit makes them incredibly soft to the touch. They are softer than our Pottery Barn Kids organic crib sheets. They’re a similar softness to our Little Unicorn Cotton Muslin crib sheets, although it’s a different feel: the jersey knit of the Burts Bees vs the muslin of the Little Unicorn sheets.

These sheets also a bit warmer to the touch than standard cotton percale, which is a design feature meant to help when you’re transitioning your baby from your arms to their crib. I was skeptical of this as a marketing thing, but they really are a bit cozier than our other crib sheets, making them a great choice in cooler weather.

My Burts Bees sheets are well used, and have very minimal, almost non-existent pilling.

A woman's hand holds a section of a Burt's Bees Baby organic crib sheet in grey stripes, with the label and Burt's Bees logo visible.

That’s another design feature, as these sheets are made from ringspun (which makes finer fibers) and combed cotton (which removes impurities after picking). This is meant to increase durability and softness, and reduce pilling.

The elastic is 360-degree design, which means it goes around the entire perimeter of the crib mattress, which is meant to keep them firmly in place.

The bottom of a crib mattress that has a Burts bees organic crib sheet on it. The photo shows the crib sheet has elastic all around the edge in a 360-degree design. The mattress is a Colgate Eco Classica III
Burts Bees organic crib sheet pictured on a Colgate Eco Classica III crib mattress.

These sheets also have a ton of extra fabric to go around the bottom of the mattress, and help keep the sheet in place. Comparing the Burt’s Bees sheet to the Pottery Barn sheet, as an example, and you can see how much more fabric the Burt’s Bees comes with. Both are absolutely adequate and meet safety requirements. However, the extra fabric on the Burt’s Bees sheet makes it a bit easier to get pulled tightly onto the mattress, in my opinion based on personal experience.

Burt's Bees organic crib sheet top left, with lots of extra fabric around the bottom edge of the crib mattress. Pottery Barn Kids organic cotton crib sheet bottom right, with limited fabric to fit around the bottom edge of the crib mattress.
Burt’s Bees organic crib sheet top left, with lots of extra fabric around the bottom edge of the crib mattress. Pottery Barn Kids organic cotton crib sheet bottom right, with limited fabric to fit around the bottom edge of the crib mattress.

The Burts Bee sheets fit a standard sized crib mattress and toddler mattress, with depth of up to 6″.

It’s worth noting, these sheets fit very tightly. Reading reviews from other customers, some people don’t love how tight they are. To me, however, this is a feature, not a bug: you really don’t want loose fabric in your kiddo’s crib, for safety reasons. Here is the sheet on a Colgate Eco Classica III crib mattress.

Collage of 4 different photos showing a Burts Bees Organic Cotton Crib sheet fitting perfectly on a Colgate Eco Classica III crib mattress

I have personally tried these sheets on a Naturepedic Breathable, Lullaby Earth, Colgate Eco Classica III, and a Nook Pebble Air. Our Burt’s Bees organic crib sheet fits perfectly on the Naturepedic, Lullaby Earth, and Colgate Eco Classica III. It’s a bit loose on the Nook Sleep Pebble Air, but if you’re diligent about really pulling the extra fabric over the edges and around the bottom, it works and the sheet stays put. This wouldn’t be my top choice crib mattress/crib sheet combination. That said, it’s worth noting the Nook Pebble mattresses can be used without sheets.

I’ve also found mentions from past customers who’ve successfully used these sheets on an Avocado crib mattress, Sealy Soybean Serenity mattress, and Newton Mattress (you can read my review of the Newton here).

Overall, I think the Burt’s Bees organic crib sheets are a great choice for most families (including my own).

Check prices, colors, and designs

(Available at Amazon, Burts Bees, or Target, and other retailers)

Jersey Knit Alternative 1: Nestig Organic Crib Sheets

We give Nestig Sheets 5/5

Nestig Crib Sheet Set in Juniper. Image courtesy of Nestig.

Ethically Made and Non Toxic

GOTS certified cotton with Oeko-Tex® certified dyes, Nestig’s gorgeous sheets are handmade in a family-run factory in Brazil. Super soft with a bit of stretch.

Check Prices, Colors, and Designs

  • Certifications: GOTS certified organic
  • Made in: Handmade in Brazil
  • Made from: GOTS certified organic cotton jersey knit with natural, non-toxic dyes for coloring (Oeko-Tex® certified dyes). 
  • Care instructions: Machine wash on warm or cold using the delicate function; tumble dry on low
  • Size: Standard
  • Elastic: Unknown

If the Burt’s Bees crib sheets don’t float your boat, but you love the idea of super soft organic jersey knit with a bit of stretch, check out Nestig.

I am a bit enamoured with Nestig as a company to be honest – they make gorgeous and ethically made cribs, crib sheets, nursery rugs, and more, and IMO the company is quite transparent about manufacturing and materials, which is a huge plus in my books.

Their handmade GOTS certified crib sheets are made using GOTS certified organic cotton and printed using Oeko-Tex® certified dyes that are all natural and non toxic.

The designs somehow strike the perfect balance between modern and vintage-whimsy, and there are plenty of Instagram-ready prints to choose from.

Unfortunately, I haven’t had a chance to try these sheets out yet. Because of this, I can’t offer a personal opinion or my own photos like I do with many of the other brands. I also don’t know if they use 360-degree elastic, or just elasticize the ends.

From what I see of Nestig crib sheets, I really like them, and they get rave reviews. But I can’t offer any personal hot takes.

Check prices, colors, and designs

Best Organic Muslin Crib Sheets: Little Unicorn

We give Little Unicorn 5/5

Best for Hot Weather and Breathability

Super soft, with some of the most adorable prints around, it’s easy to fall in love with Little Unicorn!

Check Prices, Colors, and Designs

  • Certifications: GOTS certified organic cotton; OEKO-TEX® Standard 100 certified (organic muslin sheets are certified only). Conventional cotton muslin sheets aren’t certified.
  • Made in: China
  • Made from: Little Unicorn offers sheets made from certified organic cotton muslin and conventional cotton muslin
  • Care instructions: Machine wash cold with like colors and tumble dry on low heat. If needed, use only non-chlorine bleach. Do not iron.
  • Size: 28″ x 52″ x 9″
  • Elastic: The elastic runs around the entire perimeter of the sheet

I’m mildly obsessed with these crib sheets, as they are so cute and so soft, straight out of the box.

The photo collage below shows how they fit on a Naturepedic Breathable crib mattress.

Collage of 4 photos showing the Little Unicorn crib sheets in Narwhal print on a Naturepedic Breathable Crib mattress
Little Unicorn muslin crib sheets pictured on a Naturepedic breathable crib mattress.

Little Unicorn is known for a massive range of adorable prints, making them a great choice if you have a specific nursery theme in mind, or are simply looking for super stylish crib sheets.

They make cotton muslin sheets in both an organic cotton option, and a conventional cotton option. The sheets are very soft and breathable, and would be a great choice if you want cool crib sheets, due to living in a hotter climate or to use during the summer.

The organic cotton crib sheets are GOTS certified and Oekto-Tex Standard 100 certified, meaning they’re good to go in terms of “non toxic” with dyes, pigments, and other chemicals.

We have the Narwhal print cotton muslin crib sheets. I thought they were organic when I bought them, and then got them home and realized – whoops – they aren’t, and they were final sale. I’ve reached out to Little Unicorn to ask what kind of dyes and inks they use on their conventional cotton sheets, and will update this article when (if) I hear back.

Little Unicorn does have this to say as far as a general statement on the issue:

We are parents too. And it is a lot of work. The last thing you want to worry about is the safety of the products you choose for your kids. We test and test and test again our product before it gets to you. We ensure it is free of harmful chemicals and meets global safety standards, so you can enjoy the wonderful moments through it all.

Like most crib sheets, the bottom of the sheet uses elastic around the entire perimeter. It’s pictured below on a Naturepedic Breathable crib mattress, which it fits quite well.

Bottom of a Naturepedic breathable crib mattress dressed in a Little Unicorn cotton muslin crib sheet. The photo shows the crib sheet has fitted elastic around the entire sheet.
Pictured on a Naturepedic Breathable crib mattress

I’ve tested my Little Unicorn sheets on the Naturepedic Breathable, Lullaby Earth mattress, Colgate Eco Classica III, and the Nook Pebble Air (the Air is no longer available AFAIK, but their Pebble Pure is and it’s the same dimensions). They fit well on all of them, and because the weave is so open, they have the slightest bit of stretch and give to the fabric, which makes it easier to pull them tight!

I also really like the packaging of the Little Unicorn sheets, which is plastic free. They’re packed in a sturdy cardboard box with a peekaboo window that doesn’t contain a plastic window. Yay!

A woman's hand pinches a Little Unicorn narwhal print muslin crib sheet through a window in the original packaging to demonstrate it is plastic free packaging.
Look mom! No plastic!

Check prices, colors, and designs

Best for Sensitive Skin & Eczema: Naturepedic

We give Naturepedic 5/5

Naturepedic Crib Sheets. Image courtesy Naturepedic.

All Natural for Sensitive Skin

Crib sheets from the long-reigning king of organic bedding, these are free from prints and dyes, making them a great choice for sensitive babies.
See the sheets on Naturepedic.com

  • Certifications: GOTS certified organic; MADE SAFE certified; Greenguard Gold; UL Formaldehyde Free; Climate neutral certified; 1% for the planet
  • Made in: Ethically made in a GOTS certified organic factory overseas (India, Sri Lanka or Pakistan).
  • Made from: GOTS certified organic cotton sateen
  • Care instructions: Machine wash and dry
  • Size: 28″ x 52″ x 6″
  • Elastic: The elastic runs around the entire perimeter of the sheet

Naturepedic is usually my first stop when I’m looking for something related to organic bedding, and their crib sheets get rave reviews.

They are made from a 300-thread count, long staple cotton, that is super soft.

And they forgo prints and designs in favor of keeping the sheets natural and free from dyes and pigments.

This makes them a great choice for babies with sensitive skin or skin conditions, in particular.

However, they’re also a great choice if you want a minimalist look in your nursery, and are looking for plain white crib sheets that are also organic and non-toxic.

I have used Naturepedic products before – my daughter’s crib mattress is a Naturepedic Breathable, and it’s my absolute favorite crib mattress. Her big kid bed mattress (we’ve already chosen it, but haven’t moved her into it yet) is also Naturepedic (the 2-in-1). While I haven’t had a chance to try these sheets yet, I feel comfortable recommending them based on the fact I’ve never been let down by the Naturepedic products I own.

Shop on Naturepedic.com

Sensitive Skin Alternative: Avocado Crib Sheets

We give Avocado Crib Sheets 5/5

All Natural, Organic Alternative

A solid alternative to Naturepedic, Avocado is another leader in green and non toxic sleep products for the whole family.

See the Sheets on AvocadoGreenMattress.com

  • Certifications: MADE SAFE certified; GOTS certified organic; Climate neutral certified; PETA vegan approved
  • Made in: Made in India with cotton grown by family growers in India
  • Made from: GOTS certified organic extra-long staple cotton
  • Care instructions: Machine wash in cold water on the gentle cycle usign eco-friendly and gentle detergent. Line or tumble dry on low.
  • Size: 52″ x 28″ x 10″
  • Elastic: Unknown

Avocado’s crib sheets are touted as super soft, which is a great start for babies with particularly sensitive skin. Add to that, they are 400-thread count (again: super soft) and are pre-washed and processed to ensure they have a neutral pH when they get to your crib. This is another feature meant specifically to be gentle on your baby’s skin.

Available in crisp white only, these use GOTS certified organic cotton, and are MADE SAFE certified.

Check Prices and Availability

Best Brushed Cotton with Prints: Pehr

We give Pehr 5/5

Best Printed Cotton

Pehr makes gorgeous organic baby textiles, with a massive range of cute prints. They use organic fabrics and non-toxic inks, so you don’t have to worry about and nasty stuff in your baby’s crib sheets.

Check Prices, Colors, and Designs
Shop on Maisonette and The Tot

  • Certifications: N/A
  • Made in: Designed in Canada; artisan made in India
  • Made from: Brushed organic cotton and all natural, azo-free dyes
  • Care instructions: Machine wash on cold and tumble dry on low; if required, iron on low
  • Size: 52″L x 28″ W x 8″ H
  • Elastic: The elastic runs around the entire perimeter of the sheet

I really like Pehr products. We have a Pehr organic cotton baby play mat, and it is so soft, I want to snuggle with it whenever I pull it out. It’s an awesome non-toxic baby mat, and I have come to appreciate Pehr’s commitment to organic fabrics and non-toxic inks.

Pehr also offers a wide range of adorable crib sheets with awesome prints, including gender-traditional prints, gender-neutral, bold and modern, and more subdued, traditional baby prints and colors.

Collage showing different views of a Pehr crib sheet on a crib mattress, with the Little Peeps print.
Pehr sheet pictured on a Colgate Eco Classica III crib mattress. This Little Peeps print that we have is retired!

In terms of safety, I love that Pehr’s screen printing is done by hand using azo free dyes, and the sheets are brushed organic cotton. The company only uses natural dyes and treatments, including softeners.

The bottom of a Pehr crib sheet with a full elastic perimeter visible. In my opinion the best crib sheets have a full elastic perimeter to stay in place.
Pictured on a Colgate Eco Classica III crib mattress

If choosing eco friendlier bedding is important to you, Pehr is working to reduce its packaging footprint by using fabric bags made from excess packaging for product packaging, instead of plastic.

If I was looking for a brushed cotton sheet, I’d personally choose Pehr over Pottery Barn, based on my personal experience. I find the sheets are a bit easier to get on, and also have a bit more fabric around the bottom edge.

Pehr crib sheets are meant to work on crib mattresses with a depth of up to 8″. I have tested my Pehr sheet on mattresses up to a 6″ depth (Naturepedic Breathable, Lullaby Earth, Colgate Eco Classica III, and Nook Pebble), but nothing deeper.

Check prices, colors, and designs / Shop on Maisonette / Shop on The Tot

Most Variety: Pottery Barn Kids

We give Pottery Barn Kids Organic Crib Sheets 5/5

Pottery Barn Kids organic crib sheets in an owl and bird design on a crib mattress

Our Pottery Barn Kids organic crib sheet

Plenty of Designs to Choose From

Pottery Barn Kids Organic Baby Sheets

Super soft 200 thread count organic cotton, Pottery Barn Kids has plenty of gorgeous designs and choices when it comes to fabric weave.

Check Prices, Colors, and Designs

  • Certifications: Fair Trade certified; some designs seem to use GOTS certified organic cotton, whereas others are not listed as GOTS certified.
  • Made in: Fair Trade Certified™ factory “overseas” (ours were made in Israel, but I expect this varies).
  • Made from: 100% organic cotton percale/flannel/velour etc. (PBK also offers non-organic crib sheets)
  • Care instructions: Machine wash warm on the gentle cycle, tumble dry low and remove promptly. Use only non-chlorine bleach if needed. Iron on low.
  • Size: 27.5″ x 52″. Fits a standard US crib mattress up to 10″ in depth*** (see note)
  • Elastic: On the ends, only. Not 360-degree elastic.
  • ***Note: Pottery Barn kids lists their crib sheets as fitting mattresses up to 10″ deep, but in my experience, I can’t see how that would work. In the photo below, you can see the edges of the crib sheet barely fit over a Lullaby Earth crib mattress, which is 6″ deep.

There’s a lot to love about the Pottery Barn Kids organic crib sheets.

Our PBK sheets are a cotton percale, and they’re a super soft 200-thread count with a lovely design.

They’ve been through the wash many, many times, and there is no pilling to speak of, and the print is still nice and bright.

Notice how faded the care tag is in the photo below, compared to the print on the sheet!

Collage of 4 different photos showing Pottery Barn Kids crib sheet in an owl and bird design on a crib mattress. Care tag is pictured as well, indicating the sheets are 100% organic cotton

In fact, Pottery Barn kids has some of the widest variety of organic crib sheets that I’ve found. Their organic line offers sheets made from an organic percale, organic velour, and organic flannel – all 100% cotton. They also offer a huge range of designs, as well as seasonal sheets (i.e. Christmas) and some character sheets, as well.

Incredibly popular, good quality, and extremely cute…sounds great, right?

Don’t get me wrong: I really like our Pottery Barn Kids organic crib sheets. However, I think there are a few cons with them as well.

The first thing to note about the Pottery Barn organic crib sheets is they use elastic around the top and the bottom only, not the entire edge.

Collage showing the elastic edges of Pottery Barn Kids organic cotton crib sheets. Two side by side images show where the elastic edges stop along the edges, with arrows and a label to show the elastic edge does not go all the way around on PBK sheets. Pictured on a Lullaby Earth Crib Mattress

This is unique among the crib sheets I’ve tried – every other brand I have direct experience is has a “360-degree” elastic system.

My Pottery Barn Kids crib sheets do stay in place really well. But it’s certainly worth pointing out this is a different design than you might expect.

A bigger issue for me is fit. Pottery Barn indicates the sheets should fit up to a 10″ deep mattress, but there isn’t a lot of fabric left over on the bottom when I put it on my Lullaby Earth Crib mattress (pictured immediately below), which is 6″

Bottom of a Lullaby Earth Crib mattress dressed in a Pottery Barn Kids organic crib sheet. The edges of the PBK crib sheets are visible.
My Pottery Barn Kids organic cotton crib sheet on a Lullaby Earth crib mattress.

When I put them on our 6″ deep Colgate Eco Classica III, the fabric on the non-elasticized edges of the crib sheet don’t wrap around to the bottom of the mattress – there simply isn’t enough fabric.

Edge of a Pottery Barn Kids organic crib sheet on a crib mattress
Pictured on a Colgate Eco Classica III.

The sheet fits wonderfully on our Nook Pebble Air (pictured below) which is a lower profile mattress (it’s only 4″ deep) compared to the Naturepedic Breathable, Colgate Eco Classica III, and Lullaby Earth crib mattresses I tested this sheet with.

I think this sheet fits a 6″ depth mattress just fine – it stays put. But, I can’t really see how it would work on a 10″ deep mattress, without being frustrating to get on and off. That said, I don’t have a 10″ deep mattress to try it on, so I am just guessing here.

Bottom edges of a Pottery Barn Kids organic cotton crib sheet tested for fit on a Nook Pebble Air crib mattress.

Overall, I think Pottery Barn sheets are durable, soft, and adorable, and should work with most mattresses up to 6″ deep, but I’d be wary about buying them for deeper mattresses.

Check prices, colors, and designs

Best Solid Color: Natemia Solid Color Organic Crib Sheets

We give Natemia Organic Crib Sheets 5/5

Natemia makes solid color organic crib sheets in gorgeous, modern and bold colors

Bold, Modern Colors

These sheets are gorgeous, with bold and modern colors for your bold and modern baby. They are GOTS certified, and come in a soft jersey knit.

Check Prices, Colors, and Designs

  • Certifications: GOTS certified and Oeko-Tex certified.
  • Made in: Turkey
  • Made from: 100% organic Turkish cotton. They offer both jersey knit and percale versions, although the solid colored sheets are all jersey as far as I know.
  • Size: 28″ x 52″. Fits a standard US crib mattress.
  • Elastic: The elastic runs around the entire perimeter of the sheet

A parent-founded brand focused on high-quality, natural and non toxic baby essentials that are affordable. Their crib sheets get great reviews, and the company even made Oprah’s list of favorite things for 2022!

As I haven’t tried these personally, I can’t offer my personal experience testing them out.

One thing I do love about these sheets, however, is that they come in crib size, pack n play and mini crib size, and twin! So if you love them, your big kid can continue to use the brand for years into the future.

Check Colors, Prices and Availability

Solid Color Alternative: Green Cradle Solid Colored Crib Sheets

Green Cradle is known for their craftsman quality non-toxic all wood natural baby cribs, but they also offer organic crib mattresses and organic crib sheets and bedding. Their organic cotton crib sheets are 300 thread count and available in a variety of solid colors designed to mix and match.

Check Prices, Colros and Availability

Best Organic Crib Sheets that are Made in the USA: Our Green House

Most of the crib sheets listed above are made in southeast Asia, or in unknown oversees factories.

I suspect this is likely due to the fact that GOTS cotton is often also grown in those same countries (India, in particular), and it makes sense to manufacture where the cotton is grown and processed.

However, if you’d prefer a made in the USA organic crib sheet, Our Green House sells several options, which you can find here.

Additional Organic Crib Sheets Available on Amazon:

Touched By Nature (Jersey Knit)

Touched by Nature makes 100% organic cotton jersey knit crib sheets. The types of inks and dyes they use aren’t specified.

Check Prices and Availability

Pickle & Pumpkin Organic Mini Crib Sheets (Jersey Knit)

Pickle & Pumpkin makes organic pack n play sheets and mini crib sheets. These are GOTS certified organic cotton and use 180 GSM jersey knit.

Check Prices and Availability

KeaBabies (Jersey Knit)

KeaBabies makes GOTS certified sheets that you can get in a value-focused 2-pack. These seem like a great value, and the prints are very cute!

Check Prices and Availability

A Few More Alternatives

What to Look for in Organic Crib Sheets

Here’s a checklist to consider if you want to choose the best crib sheets for your family.

Remember, safe sleep guidelines dictate that nothing else should be in your baby’s crib: just the crib, a tight-fitting firm crib mattress, and a tight-fitting crib sheet with no loose or extra fabric.

That means no stuffed animals, pillows, blankets, crib bumpers, etc.

While you’re sure to come across plenty of adorable crib bedding when decorating your nursery, a lone, tight-fitting crib sheet is the only baby bed linen you need for the first year.

A Tight Fitting, Fitted Sheet

The American Academy of Pediatrics Safe Sleep guidelines call for using a tight fitting, fitted sheet in your baby’s crib or bassinet.

Most (but not all) baby crib sheets have elastic along the entire perimeter of the sheet, not just at the top and bottom, or around the four corners, as with fitted sheets meant for older kids and adults.

This 360° elastic design is meant to ensure the fitted sheet stays snugly in place while your baby is sleeping. That said, some reputable brands (eg. Pottery Barn Kids) only have elastic at the ends of the sheet.

I own crib sheets with both a full perimeter elastic design, and elastic just at the end. In my personal experience and opinion, both have been fine, and have stayed in place well. However, you’ll need to ensure your specific sheets fit well (aka: tightly and securely) with your specific crib mattress before letting your baby sleep on them.

Sheets that don’t fit snugly, or that don’t stay put, risk loose fabric gathering near your baby while sleeping, which is hazardous.

Before using your new crib sheet with your baby, try it out on the crib mattress, and ensure it fits properly and tightly, and stays put without too much slipping.

Pre-washed Cotton

Given the importance of a tight fit when it comes to crib sheets, you’ll want to buy a sheet that has been pre-washed to minimize shrinkage when it comes time to launder it yourself.

Pre-washed sheets also tend to be softer, making for a happier baby, and less irritated baby skin.

Cotton in particular is well-suited for crib sheets, as it can stand up to frequent laundering, and organic cotton tends to be more durable due to the way its picked and processed.

Mattress Depth

While some brands of crib sheet fit up to 9″ mattress depth, others are much shallower, fitting a crib mattress depth of only 5″.

Be sure to check your own crib mattress depth when shopping for a crib sheet to ensure the sheet will fit.

I’ve personally tested some of the sheets included on this list with 4 different crib mattresses I have at my house: the Naturepedic Breathable, the Lullaby Earth, the Colgate Eco Classica III, and a Nook Pebble mattress.

Non Toxic Dyes and Inks

If you plan to buy a printed crib sheet, look for bedding brands that use water-based, natural and non-toxic dyes, and azo-free dyes in particular.

While many organic crib sheet makers choose to highlight the fact that they use non-toxic dyes, not all do, so it’s worth checking.

Crib sheets that are certified as GOTS or Oeko-Tex have to follow the independent rules and regulations around dyeing – both the dyes used and the process – set by those organizations as safe.

If you’re concerned, or your baby is particularly sensitive, you might want to consider unprinted, plain white organic crib sheets from either Naturepedic or Avocado.

Eco Friendly

Choosing organic baby bedding is certainly a step up from conventional cotton and synthetic fibers from an eco friendly and sustainable point of view.

However, if you’re looking for the best eco crib sheets, consider the packaging as well.

Many of the companies I’ve listed below use fabric packaging for their sheets, instead of plastic or vinyl, which is a huge win in my books!

Certifications

GOTS – GOTS stands for Global Organic Textile Standard, and it refers to the finished product. That means both the raw inputs (i.e. yarn and fabric; dyes and pigments; etc.) and the processes and techniques used to create that finished product must be compliant.

GOTS requires dyes be biodegradable and non toxic during “wet processing” which you can read about here, and has a wide-ranging set of requirements within their main key features.

OEKO-TEX® Standard 100 certified: Several of the organic baby crib sheets listed below are OEKO-TEX® Standard 100 certified.

This means every aspect of the sheet has been tested for for harmful substances and found to be harmless for human health, including decorative prints as well as any coatings or fabric finishes used on the finished product.

With regards to dyes, OEKO-TEX® Standard 100 certified crib sheets have had their inputs tested for banned azo dyes, and colorants/pigments that are known to be carcinogenic or allergenic.

MADE SAFE: Of the sheets I’ve included in this list of the best crib sheets, only Naturepedic and Avocado have achieved the MADE SAFE certification. This certification means the product has been made with safe “ingredients” and it focuses on safety from both a human health and ecological/environmental point of view.

Terms Worth Knowing When Shopping for Crib Bedding

If you’re struggling to figure out the difference between sateen and percale, brushed cotton and jersey knit – and what it all means for your baby – I’ve outlined it below.

Note, lots of brands don’t specify which type of knit or finish they use on their crib sheets. If they do specify, I’ve listed the brands below as best as I could.

Jersey Knit

Jersey knit is super soft and has a bit of stretch, which is honestly pretty handy when it comes to stretching a crib sheet over your baby’s mattress.

My pick for the best crib sheets ever (Burt’s Bees Baby) are jersey knit, and it’s no coincidence: the softnesss and the stretch makes them awesome.

Other 100% cotton jersey knit sheets I’ve included on this list include those from Nestig, Touched by Nature at Target, and Natemia Solid Color crib sheets.

Organic Muslin

Muslin crib bedding has a larger, more open weave than other types of cotton, so is particularly breathable. Choose an organic cotton muslin crib sheet if you live in a hot climate or want something extra breathable for the summer and warm nights.

Brushed Cotton

A woven fabric that is brushed during processing to add softness. Also sometimes known as flannelette.

Caring for Organic Crib Sheets

While babies love super soft crib sheets, parents and caregivers tend to love products that last a long time, and don’t need constant replacements.

As it happens, how you choose to care for your baby’s crib sheet can achieve both of those goals.

Proper care will help keep it soft and extend its lifespan, allowing you to use it well into the toddler years.

Almost all of the crib sheet brands I’ve listed above recommend you use the gentle cycle when (machine) washing your sheets, and washing with like colors. Use eco-friendly and/or gentle/mild detergent to care better for the organic fabric, and choose fragrance free to reduce phthalates in your home.

In terms of drying your crib sheet, you can line dry or tumble dry on a low heat setting.

If you do use your dryer, remove the crib sheet promptly once the cycle is complete to reduce wrinkles. If needed, iron using low heat.

When using a tumble dryer, don’t use dryer sheets for baby bedding and clothes – opt for dryer sheet alternatives like Attitude anti-static sheets or natural wool dyer balls.

If your crib sheet has stains that require heavier duty treatment, check with the specific brand you’re using before using a baby-safe stain remover or non-chlorine bleach. Certain pigments or dyes used to print the sheets may require specific care in terms of stain removal.

Why Choose Organic for Your Baby’s Crib Sheet?

While I don’t think organic crib sheets are essential, and families shouldn’t feel ashamed if they choose not to buy organic, there are some legitimate reasons you might want to choose organic crib sheets.

Organic Cotton Sheets are Softer and More Durable

Generally speaking, organic cotton crib sheets are softer and more durable than those made from conventional cotton.

This comes down to how organic cotton is picked and processed vs the conventional stuff, leaving organic cotton with longer, smoother and stronger fibres.

In conventional cotton harvesting, chemical herbicides are applied to the plants to make mechanical picking easier. Both the chemicals and the machine picking can damage the cotton fibers, resulting in shorter cotton fibers than in organic cotton, which tends to be hand-picked, without the use of defoliating chemicals.

Those shorter cotton fibres found in conventional cotton products explain why its not as soft or as durable as organic cotton fibres.

They’re Better for the Environment

Conventional cotton (and the pesticides used during growing, and chemicals used during harvesting) is horrendous for the environment. If you’d like to learn more about this, The Deadly Chemicals in Cotton is a comprehensive read on the subject.

Choosing organic cotton helps to protect workers, eco systems, and our drinking water supplies.

There is a Great Selection

The demand for organic cotton – and the organic cotton market size – has grown massively since 2017. And organic cotton is no longer completely out of reach, price wise, due to the demand. Now it’s easier than ever to choose organic.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Thoughts

Whether you choose organic crib sheets or conventional, the best crib sheets for your family are ones that fit your crib mattress well, are easy to get on and off, and work without your needs – budget included. Personally, I have both conventional and organic cotton crib sheets, and there are a lot of merits to choosing organic. If you’re not as concerned about organic, I encourage you to consider what kind of dyes and inks the company uses, and ensure those are non toxic.

My favorite organic crib sheets are the Burt’s Bees brand, based on personal experience. However, I hope I’ve offered a wide selection to choose from!

Share this Post

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Don’t miss our regular updates, new content, and free offers!

Scroll to Top
Skip to content